A dim-witted king, an independent heroine, and enough theatrical Easter eggs to keep Broadway obsessives busy all night. The King's Critique isn't reinventing the musical, but with a terrific ensemble, infectious energy, and a healthy dose of royal absurdity, who cares?
Credit: Russ Rowland (2026)//Gabi Carrubba (Isabella) and Justin Collette (King Benjamin)
Undoubtedly fun and just a little bit ridiculous (in the best way), The King's Critique, a new musical by Eric Holmes and Nat Zegree, is perfectly situated in the Romulus Linney Theatre at Pershing Square. Hovering between the worlds of Shakespeare in Love and Something Rotten, The King’s Critique had us laughing and tapping our toes along with the band from the first number.
With nods to the mistaken identity tropes of Will Shakespeare, the deliberately mishandled performances of The Producers, and the strong-female-through-a-modern-lens of such films as 10 Things I Hate About You, King’s Critique is not doing anything we haven't seen before, yet somehow, it still feels fresh.
Theatre fans will enjoy keeping their ears peeled for Easter eggs from shows such as The Wizard of Oz, The Book of Mormon, and Wicked, just to name a few.
The true strength of this piece lay in the ensemble cast, who filled the space with tableaux and brought great life to the stage. They had each put in the work, creating fleshed-out characters and fun moments, even if they didn't get much to say; there was always some detail to notice. Despite the small size of some roles, the composer allowed them time to shine, with some of the ensemble harmonies ranking among my favorite moments of the night.
Credit: Russ Rowland (2026)//The cast of The King’s Critique
Portrayed by Justin Collette (of Broadway's Beetlejuice and School of Rock), flamboyant, adorable, and dim-witted King Benjamin stole the show. With impeccable comic timing, Collette made the guy you love to hate a little more lovable. His Influencer-era consort, Isabella, was another stand-out. Played by Gabi Carrubba (recently seen in an awesome NYCC production of Bat Boy), Isabella was sassy and fabulous, and Carrubba pitched her performance just right, walking the fine line of vapid while remaining fun and quippy, instead of making us all roll our eyes.
And leading lady/brother lover Josephine, played by SIX's Taylor Iman Jones, carried the story. She was fierce and independent, with a rad belt and beautifully emotive face, and created a strong anchor that had the audience on-side and grounded the entire production.
The set was cleverly designed for the space, allowing an in-the-round experience for the audience, utilizing different levels for an immersive and interesting visual experience. Emily Rebholz's costumes, combining Elizabethan dress with modern prints and footwear, brought the piece a stylish yet fitting edge, and felt like the perfect finishing touch.
Credit: Russ Rowland (2026)//Sky Lakota-Lynch (Sebastian) and Taylor Iman Jones (Josephine)
I was also impressed with the choreography from Nancy Renee Braun, who didn't shy away from movement despite the smaller space, and made it feel not cramped, but full and alive. The ensemble dances greatly contributed to the jubilant and enjoyable feel of the whole play. There were also several creative scene transitions, cleverly executed, making the changes engaging instead of dead space.
Personally, I didn't like the romantic plot line; it took away from Josephine's story and was not necessary at all. But that was my only issue with the whole production.
And while it could have simply been a play about fighting our oppressors, sticking it to the man, the futility and stupidity of governments, and even feminism, at its heart The King's Critique boils down to why we make art, together. How very human—and hopeful—it is. Off-Broadway was abuzz with cheers and laughter on Saturday night, and while I could envisage The King’s Critique transferring to a bigger stage, I actually think it works so well in its current home, it deserves to sell out for many an extended run. I highly recommend you get along to see this one.